Journal of Clinical Medicine Research, ISSN 1918-3003 print, 1918-3011 online, Open Access
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, J Clin Med Res and Elmer Press Inc
Journal website https://www.jocmr.org

Original Article

Volume 15, Number 2, February 2023, pages 116-126


Symptom Profile of Patients With Post-COVID-19 Conditions and Influencing Factors for Recovery

Figures

Figure 1.
Figure 1. Improvement status of post-COVID-19 conditions. COVID-19: coronavirus disease 2019.
Figure 2.
Figure 2. The use of zinc acetate hydrate and improvement status of post-COVID-19 conditions after 12 weeks. *P < 0.05, comparison with use of zinc acetate hydrate. Fisher’s exact test. COVID-19: coronavirus disease 2019.

Tables

Table 1. Patient Profile and Follow-Up Status in Treatment of Post-COVID-19 Conditions
 
ItemnMale/femaleAge (years)Hypozincemia caseNumber of cases followed up after 12 weeks
Data are mean ± standard deviation or n (%). COVID-19: coronavirus disease 2019.
Overall12044/7637.4 ± 12.953 (44.2%)108 (90.0%)
Fatigue5619/3737.6 ± 11.924 (42.9%)49 (87.5%)
Breathlessness64/240.3 ± 9.43 (50.0%)6 (100.0%)
Cough/sputum288/2037.9 ± 13.816 (57.1%)27 (96.4%)
Decline in cognitive dysfunction/concentration104/633.6 ± 11.95 (50.0%)8 (80.0%)
Headache359/2637.3 ± 13.114 (40.0%)30 (85.7%)
Diarrhea204/1641.1 ± 12.410 (50.0%)16 (80.0%)
Taste disorder7724/5336.7 ± 13.236 (46.8%)74 (96.1%)
Olfactory disorder7020/5036.5 ± 13.434 (48.6%)67 (95.7%)
Hair loss4210/3237.0 ± 14.115 (35.7%)39 (92.9%)
Depression82/643.6 ± 10.23 (37.5%)7 (87.5%)

 

Table 2. The First-Visit Test Values in All Patients
 
ItemnMean ± SDRef.
Ref.: reference value; AST: aspartate aminotransferase; ALT: alanine aminotransferase; ALP: alkaline phosphatase; ChE: cholinesterase; γ-GT: γ-glutamyl transpeptidase; TP: total protein; ALB: albumin; CRP: C-reactive protein; WBC: white blood cell; Hb: hemoglobin; PLT: platelet; LIP: lipase; TG: triglyceride; LDL-C: low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; UA: uric acid; Na: sodium; Cl: chlorine; K: potassium; Ca: calcium; P: phosphorus; Mg: magnesium; Zn: zinc; Cu: copper; eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate; BG: blood glucose; VB2: vitamin B2, VB12: vitamin B12; FT4: free thyroxine; TSH: thyroid-stimulating hormone; SD: standard deviation.
AST (U/L)11722.2 ± 8.610 - 40
ALT (U/L)11723.1 ± 19.75 - 40
ALP (U/L)11767.3 ± 28.938 - 113
ChE (U/L)117332.9 ± 71.6M: 242 - 495, F: 200 - 459
γ-GT (U/L)11733.9 ± 62.4M: ≤ 70, F: ≤ 30
TP (g/dL)1177.21 ± 0.466.7 - 8.3
ALB (g/dL)1174.42 ± 0.383.8 - 5.2
CRP (mg/dL)1170.180 ± 0.663≤ 0.14
WBC (/µL)1166458 ± 1516M: 3,900 - 9,800, F: 3,500 - 9,100
Hb (g/dL)11713.87 ± 1.63M: 13.5 - 17.6, F: 11.3 - 15.2
PLT (× 104/µL)11724.53 ± 5.96M: 13.1 - 36.2, F: 13.0 - 36.9
LIP (U/L)11632.3 ± 22.413 - 55
TG (mg/dL)117111.3 ± 77.650 - 149
LDL-C (mg/dL)117113.3 ± 30.370 - 139
UA (mg/dL)1175.00 ± 1.42M: 3.7 - 7.0, F: 2.5 - 7.0
Na (mEq/L)117140.8 ± 1.9136 - 147
Cl (mEq/L)117101.9 ± 2.498 - 109
K (mEq/L)1174.23 ± 0.493.6 - 5.0
Ca (mg/dL)1179.11 ± 0.418.5 - 10.2
P (mg/dL)1173.16 ± 0.562.4 - 4.3
Mg (mg/dL)1172.28 ± 0.171.8 - 2.6
Zn (µg/dL)11283.7 ± 17.480 - 130
Cu (µg/dL)117105.9 ± 22.268 - 128
eGFR (mL/min/1.73 m2)10188.18 ± 19.36
BG (mg/dL)11898.3 ± 27.370 - 109
VB2 (ng/mL)9396.68 ± 17.1366.1 - 111.4
VB12 (pg/mL)94351.2 ± 198.3180 - 914
FT4 (ng/dL)841.28 ± 0.170.75 - 1.45
TSH (µU/mL)831.72 ± 0.970.61 - 4.23

 

Table 3. Analysis Results of Improvement Factors After 12 Weeks for Post-COVID-19 Conditions
 
ItemFatigueTaste disorderOlfactory disorderHair loss
OR95% CIPOR95% CIPOR95% CIPOR95% CIP
*P < 0.05 Wald’s Chi-squared test. The calculation was not permitted for fatigue since the symptom was improved in all of the cases of the group treated with zinc acetate hydrate. AST: aspartate aminotransferase; ALT: alanine aminotransferase; ALP: alkaline phosphatase; ChE: cholinesterase; γ-GT: γ-glutamyl transpeptidase; TP: total protein; ALB: albumin; CRP: C-reactive protein; WBC: white blood cell; Hb: hemoglobin; PLT: platelet; LIP: lipase; TG: triglyceride; LDL-C: low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; UA: uric acid; Na: sodium; Cl: chlorine; K: potassium; Ca: calcium; P: phosphorus; Mg: magnesium; Zn: zinc; Cu: copper; eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate; BG: blood glucose.
Use of zinc acetate hydrate-0 - Inf-1.100.36 - 3.440.8631.220.41 - 3.670.72514.001.58 - 124.000.018*
Sex (male: 1; female: 0)0.280.04 - 1.870.1890.950.29 - 3.170.9330.710.22 - 2.300.5710.540.12 - 2.470.424
Age (years)0.980.91 - 1.060.6920.970.93 - 1.020.2391.000.96 - 1.040.9501.020.97 - 1.070.534
AST (U/L)1.150.89 - 1.480.2990.970.91 - 1.040.3820.990.92 - 1.060.7240.980.90 - 1.070.678
ALT (U/L)1.030.93 - 1.140.5690.990.96 - 1.020.5520.990.96 - 1.020.4000.980.95 - 1.020.328
ALP (U/L)0.990.97 - 1.010.4820.970.94 - 1.000.0650.980.95 - 1.010.1721.000.95 - 1.040.822
ChE (U/L)1.000.99 - 1.020.8381.000.99 - 1.010.5141.000.99 - 1.000.3000.990.98 - 1.000.185
γ-GT (U/L)1.090.91 - 1.300.3681.000.98 - 1.010.7831.000.98 - 1.020.7380.990.97 - 1.020.469
TP (g/dL)0.260.01 - 4.710.3642.810.84 - 9.440.0952.220.72 - 6.830.1661.000.20 - 4.971.000
ALB (g/dL)0.230.01 - 6.360.3884.220.60 - 29.700.1482.250.43 - 11.900.3381.370.29 - 6.470.691
CRP (mg/dL)1.980.01 - 577.000.8131.100.05 - 25.900.9531.320.06 - 27.700.8572.020.17 - 23.700.575
WBC (/µL)1.001.00 - 1.000.5391.001.00 - 1.000.8851.001.00 - 1.000.6671.001.00 - 1.000.495
Hb (g/dL)0.400.16 - 1.010.0530.950.64 - 1.400.7810.820.57 - 1.170.2680.770.47 - 1.240.278
PLT (× 104/µL)1.080.90 - 1.310.3940.920.84 - 1.010.0760.930.85 - 1.010.0910.970.88 - 1.070.539
LIP (U/L)1.050.94 - 1.170.4251.010.98 - 1.050.5061.010.98 - 1.040.5891.010.97 - 1.070.578
TG (mg/dL)1.010.99 - 1.030.4391.000.99 - 1.010.8421.000.99 - 1.000.6481.000.99 - 1.010.801
LDL-C (mg/dL)1.000.96 - 1.030.8310.990.97 - 1.010.3190.990.97 - 1.000.1480.990.97 - 1.010.381
UA (mg/dL)1.060.49 - 2.310.8770.980.65 - 1.480.9350.830.56 - 1.210.3260.770.50 - 1.190.235
Na (mEq/L)0.670.38 - 1.170.1611.040.76 - 1.420.7990.920.66 - 1.280.6230.970.64 - 1.470.887
Cl (mEq/L)0.980.51 - 1.870.9551.090.90 - 1.310.3981.180.93 - 1.500.1691.230.81 - 1.860.335
K (mEq/L)0.220.02 - 2.000.1791.060.31 - 3.640.9291.530.45 - 5.290.4983.220.45 - 22.800.242
Ca (mg/dL)0.330.02 - 5.740.4451.850.48 - 7.190.3740.730.18 - 3.010.6663.660.41 - 32.500.245
P (mg/dL)1.060.15 - 7.340.9530.670.26 - 1.720.4080.610.23 - 1.580.3060.950.32 - 2.790.927
Mg (mg/dL)0.710 - 902.000.9250.600.03 - 13.100.7480.230.01 - 4.430.3301.170.02 - 79.100.943
Zn (µg/dL)0.980.95 - 1.010.2591.010.96 - 1.050.7060.970.93 - 1.010.1370.940.89 - 1.000.043*
Cu (µg/dL)1.070.99 - 1.150.0891.000.98 - 1.030.8451.000.98 - 1.030.9821.000.96 - 1.030.806
eGFR (mL/min/1.73 m2)1.030.96 - 1.110.3561.020.98 - 1.060.3641.010.98 - 1.050.4001.010.96 - 1.070.630
BG (mg/dL)1.000.96 - 1.040.9311.010.99 - 1.040.4171.000.98 - 1.020.9611.000.95 - 1.050.959

 

Table 4. Analysis Results of Improvement Factors After 4 Weeks for Post-COVID-19 Conditions
 
ItemFatigueHair loss
OR95% CIPOR95% CIP
*P < 0.05 Wald’s Chi-squared test. AST: aspartate aminotransferase; ALT: alanine aminotransferase; ALP: alkaline phosphatase; ChE: cholinesterase; γ-GT: γ-glutamyl transpeptidase; TP: total protein; ALB: albumin; CRP: C-reactive protein; WBC: white blood cell; Hb: hemoglobin; PLT: platelet; LIP: lipase; TG: triglyceride; LDL-C: low-density lipoprotein cholesterol; UA: uric acid; Na: sodium; Cl: chlorine; K: potassium; Ca: calcium; P: phosphorus; Mg: magnesium; Zn: zinc; Cu: copper; eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate; BG: blood glucose; CI: confidence interval.
Use of zinc acetate hydrate2.220.50 - 9.850.29510.402.31 - 47.300.002*
Sex (male: 1; female: 0)0.390.09 - 1.630.1982.160.48 - 9.770.318
Age (years)0.950.89 - 1.010.1120.990.95 - 1.040.694
AST (U/L)1.040.91 - 1.200.5691.050.96 - 1.140.330
ALT (U/L)1.030.96 - 1.100.4211.000.97 - 1.040.841
ALP (U/L)0.990.98 - 1.010.4440.990.95 - 1.040.758
ChE (U/L)1.000.99 - 1.010.9161.000.99 - 1.010.890
γ-GT (U/L)1.000.96 - 1.040.9131.000.98 - 1.030.818
TP (g/dL)1.810.33 - 9.950.4920.300.06 - 1.560.150
ALB (g/dL)1.410.18 - 10.900.7452.510.47 - 13.500.283
CRP (mg/dL)352.000 - 45,900,0000.3292.850.33 - 24.800.344
WBC (/µL)1.001.00 - 1.000.3931.001.00 - 1.000.050
Hb (g/dL)0.520.27 - 1.010.0521.220.78 - 1.940.386
PLT (× 104/µL)1.140.98 - 1.320.0840.930.84 - 1.030.188
LIP (U/L)1.020.97 - 1.070.4651.010.97 - 1.060.630
TG (mg/dL)1.021.00 - 1.040.0881.000.99 - 1.010.681
LDL-C (mg/dL)1.000.98 - 1.030.8361.000.98 - 1.020.683
UA (mg/dL)1.090.63 - 1.890.7681.060.70 - 1.590.792
Na (mEq/L)0.640.42 - 0.990.045*1.010.68 - 1.500.967
Cl (mEq/L)0.650.39 - 1.080.0961.050.71 - 1.550.826
K (mEq/L)0.580.13 - 2.640.4784.560.58 - 36.100.150
Ca (mg/dL)0.960.15 - 6.250.9681.410.21 - 9.480.724
P (mg/dL)2.730.57 - 13.200.2101.320.47 - 3.720.606
Mg (mg/dL)65.800.18 - 24,0000.1640.170.00 - 11.500.412
Zn (µg/dL)1.000.96 - 1.030.7660.960.91 - 1.020.162
Cu (µg/dL)1.061.01 - 1.130.026*0.970.93 - 1.010.106
eGFR (mL/min/1.73 m2)1.061.01 - 1.130.033*1.010.96 - 1.050.791
BG (mg/dL)0.990.96 - 1.020.4311.020.97 - 1.070.399

 

Table 5. Multivariate Analysis Results for Improvement Factors of Symptoms 4 or 12 Weeks Later
 
ItemOdds ratio95% CIP-value
We employed the use of zinc acetate hydrate for hair loss because of the greater practical impact, comparing zinc acetate hydrate and zinc. We used the items with P < 0.25 in univariate analysis in the Wald chi-squared test for multivariate analysis (We used the items with P < 0.1 for analysis of fatigue). *P < 0.05 Wald chi-squared test. Hb: hemoglobin; PLT: platelet; TG: triglyceride; Na: sodium; Cl: chlorine; Cu: copper; eGFR: estimated glomerular filtration rate; ALP: alkaline phosphatase; TP: total protein; ALB: albumin; Zn: zinc; WBC: white blood cell; K: potassium; CI: confidence interval.
Fatigue (4 weeks)
  Hb0.200.03 - 1.200.079
  PLT0.970.67 - 1.410.891
  TG1.040.99 - 1.090.145
  Na0.840.40 - 1.770.643
  Cl0.910.32 - 2.590.867
  Cu1.060.97 - 1.160.216
  eGFR1.160.98 - 1.370.084
Taste disorder (12 weeks)
  Age0.980.93 - 1.030.384
  ALP0.980.94 - 1.010.164
  TP2.240.67 - 7.520.192
  ALB2.020.35 - 11.700.433
  PLT0.940.85 - 1.040.247
Olfactory disorder (12 weeks)
  ALP0.990.95 - 1.020.416
  TP2.760.62 - 12.200.181
  PLT0.950.87 - 1.050.336
  Cl1.140.92 - 1.410.244
  Zn0.980.93 - 1.020.300
Hair loss (4 weeks)
  Use of zinc acetate hydrate48.032.74 - 840.500.008*
  TP2.330.06 - 96.180.656
  WBC1.001.00 - 1.000.056
  PLT1.060.87 - 1.300.540
  K123.072.12 - 7146.760.020*
  Cu0.960.88 - 1.030.256