Journal of Clinical Medicine Research, ISSN 1918-3003 print, 1918-3011 online, Open Access
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, J Clin Med Res and Elmer Press Inc
Journal website https://www.jocmr.org

Original Article

Volume 14, Number 9, September 2022, pages 364-376


Frailty in Portuguese Older Patients From Convalescence Units: A Cross-Sectional Study

Tables

Table 1. Sociodemographic Characterization of the Sample
 
Total (n = 165)Non-frail (n = 33)Frail (n = 132)P-value
aMarried vs. others. bNone vs. others. CS: Chi-square test; MW: Mann-Whitney test; FT: Fisher’s test.
Gender, n (%)CS: 0.002
  Male58 (35.2%)19 (57.6%)39 (29.5%)
  Female107 (64.8%)14 (42.4%)93 (70.5%)
Age (years), median (min. - max.)77.0 (60.0 - 96.0)76.0 (60.0 - 88.0)77.0 (60.0 - 96.0)MW: 0.297
Marital status, n (%)FT: 0.016a
  Single23 (14.0%)0 (0.0%)23 (17.6%)
  Married/living with partner45 (27.4%)8 (24.2%)37 (28.2%)
  Separated/divorced17 (10.4%)5 (15.2%)12 (9.2%)
  Widowed79 (48.2%)20 (60.6%)59 (45.0%)
Living area, n (%)CS: 0.937
  Urban74 (44.8%)15 (45.5%)59 (44.7%)
  Rural91 (55.2%)18 (54.5%)73 (55.3%)
Educational level, n (%)FT: 0.118b
  None31 (18.9%)3 (9.1%)28 (21.4%)
  1 - 4 years99 (60.4%)22 (66.7%)77 (58.8%)
  5 - 6 years12 (7.3%)2 (6.1%)10 (7.6%)
  7 - 9 years10 (6.1%)5 (15.2%)5 (3.8%)
  10 - 12 years---
  University1 (0.6%)0 (0.0%)1 (0.8%)
  Other11 (6.7%)1 (3.0%)10 (7.6%)

 

Table 2. Health-Related Parameters of the Study
 
Total (n = 165)Non-frail (n = 33)Frail (n = 132)P-value
Missing data: marital status (n = 1), educational level (n = 1), number of medicines per day (n = 2). CS: Chi-square test; MW: Mann-Whitney test; FT: Fisher’s test; BMI: body mass index; SBP: systolic blood pressure; DBP: diastolic blood pressure.
Weight (kg), mean (SD)68.62 (14.04)71.71 (11.42)67.88 (14.54)FT: 0.173
Height (cm), median (min. - max.)160.0 (148.0 - 184.0)165.0 (148.0 - 175.0)160.0 (148.0 - 184.0)MW: 0.005
BMI (kg/m2), median (min. - max.)25.5 (13.0 - 42.8)25.6 (18.3 - 34.3)25.3 (13.0 - 42.8)MW: 0.528
Weight loss in the previous year, n (%)87 (55.4%)13 (40.6%)74 (59.2%)CS: 0.059
SBP (mm Hg), median (min. - max.)120.0 (86.0 - 181.0)120.0 (95.0 - 181.0)120.0 (86.0 - 160.0)MW: 0.812
DBP (mm Hg), median (min. - max.)70.0 (40.0 - 100.0)70.0 (42.0 - 82.0)70.0 (40.0 - 100.0)MW: 0.812
Hospitalized in the previous year, n (%)125 (76.2%)26 (78.8%)99 (75.6%)CS: 0.698
Number of hospitalizations in the previous year, median (min. - max.)1.0 (1.0 - 8.0)1.0 (1.0 - 1.0)1.0 (1.0 - 8.0)MW: 0.018
Frequently tired in the previous 3 months, n (%)94 (57.0%)10 (30.3%)84 (63.6%)CS: 0.000
Feeling full of energy at this time, n (%)71 (43.0%)23 (69.7%)48 (31.3%)CS: 0.000
Sphincter incontinence (urine/feces), n (%)49 (29.7%)3 (9.1%)46 (34.8%)CS: 0.004
Memory changes, n (%)65 (39.9%)10 (30.3%)55 (42.3%)CS: 0.208
Pacemaker holder, n (%)11 (7.0%)1 (3.2%)10 (7.9%)FT: 0.694
Cardiac disease, n (%)72 (50.3%)8 (27.6%)64 (56.1%)CS: 0.006
Heart failure, n (%)37 (67.3%)3 (60.0%)34 (68.0%)FT: > 0.999
Auricular fibrillation, n (%)31 (56.4%)2 (40.0%)29 (58.0%)FT: 0.643
Neurologic disease, n (%)54 (40.6%)9 (32.1%)45 (42.9%)FT: 0.388
Stroke, n (%)31 (57.4%)5 (55.6%)26 (57.8%)FT: > 0.999
Parkinson disease, n (%)1 (1.9%)-1 (2.2%)FT: > 0.999
Mild cognitive impairment, n (%)15 (27.8%)4 (44.4%)11 (24.4%)FT: 0.244
Vascular disease, n (%)52 (39.1%)6 (21.4%)46 (43.8%)CS: 0.031
Respiratory disease, n (%)28 (21.7%)2 (6.9%)26 (26.0%)CS: 0.028
Asthma, n (%)6 (24.0%)1 (50.0%)5 (21.7%)FT: 0.430
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, n (%)19 (76.0%)1 (50.0%)18 (78.3%)FT: 0.430
Osteoarticular disease, n (%)96 (71.1%)17 (58.6%)79 (74.5%)CS: 0.094
Gastrointestinal disease, n (%)25 (18.4%)3 (10.3%)22 (20.6%)CS: 0.208
Diabetes/other metabolic disease, n (%)55 (37.4%)8 (25.8%)47 (40.5%)CS: 0.132
Depression/other psychiatric disease, n (%)51 (37.2%)5 (17.9%)46 (42.2%)CS: 0.018
Number of medicines per day, n (%)FT: 0.088
  None5 (3.1%)2 (6.1%)3 (2.3%)
  1 - 555 (33.7%)15 (45.5%)40 (30.8%)
  > 5103 (63.2%)16 (48.5%)87 (66.9%)
Vision problems, n (%)109 (67.3%)15 (46.9%)94 (72.3%)CS: 0.006
Hearing problems, n (%)40 (24.4%)5 (15.6%)35 (26.5%)CS: 0.198
Difficulty in walking in the previous 3 months, n (%)142 (86.1%)24 (72.7%)118 (89.4%)FT: 0.022
Difficulty in climbing stairs in the previous 3 months, n (%)140 (85.4%)24 (72.7%)116 (88.5%)FT: 0.029
Use of walking auxiliary, n (%)112 (68.7%)21 (63.6%)91 (70.0%)CS: 0.481
Chronic wound, n (%)6 (3.6%)-6 (4.5%)FT: 0.601
Feeling any kind of pain, n (%)86 (52.4%)10 (30.3%)76 (58.0%)CS: 0.004
Having suffered a fall, n (%)104 (63.4%)16 (48.5%)88 (67.2%)CS: 0.046
Disability due to falls, n (%)49 (48.5%)8 (53.3%)41 (47.7%)CS: 0.686

 

Table 3. Lifestyle Parameters Assessment of the Study Sample
 
Total (n = 165)Non-frail (n = 33)Frail (n = 132)P-value
CS: Chi-square test; CSeT: Chi-square exact test; FT: Fisher’s test.
Sleeping hours per day, n (%)CSeT: 0.270
  Less than 5 h27 (16.4%)2 (6.1%)25 (18.9%)
  5 - 7 h101 (61.2%)22 (66.7%)79 (59.8%)
  8 - 10 h36 (21.8%)9 (27.3%)27 (20.5%)
  More than 10 h1 (0.6%)-1 (0.8%)
Number of meals per day, n (%)CSeT: 0.979
  Two meals2 (1.2%)-2 (1.5%)
  Three meals30 (18.2%)6 (18.2%)24 (18.2%)
  Four meals66 (40.0%)14 (42.4%)52 (39.4%)
  Five or more meals67 (40.6%)13 (39.4%)54 (40.9%)
Alcohol consumption, n (%)60 (36.4%)17 (51.5%)43 (32.6%)CS: 0.043
Smoking habits, n (%)9 (5.5%)4 (12.1%)5 (3.8%)FT: 0.080
Physical activity, n (%)33 (20.0%)11 (33.3%)22 (16.7%)CS: 0.032
Autonomous person, n (%)72 (43.6%)23 (69.7%)49 (37.1%)CS: < 0.001
How do you perceive your health status, n (%)CSeT: < 0.001
  Very good3 (1.8%)1 (3.0%)2 (1.5%)
  Good48 (29.1%)18 (54.5%)30 (22.7%)
  Regular71 (43.0%)14 (42.4%)57 (43.2%)
  Bad31 (18.8%)0 (0.0%)31 (23.5%)
  Very bad12 (7.3%)0 (0.0%)12 (9.1%)

 

Table 4. Results From Assessment Instruments
 
Total (n = 165)Non-frail (n = 33)Frail (n = 132)P-value
CS: Chi-square independent test; CSeT: Chi-square exact test; MW: Mann-Whitney test; FT: Fisher’s test; MMSE: mini-mental state examination; HADS: hospital anxiety and depression scale. Missing data: Gijon’s Social-familial Scale (n = 27), Katz index (n = 5), Lawton index (n = 6), Barthel index (n = 2), HADS depression (n = 5), and HADS anxiety (n = 5).
Glasgow coma scale
  Score, median (min. - max.)15.0 (13.0 - 15.0)15.0 (14.0 - 15.0)15.0 (13.0 - 15.0)MW: 0.793
  Category, n (%)FT: > 0.999
    12 - 14 points17 (10.3%)3 (9.1%)14 (10.6%)
    Normal 15 points148 (89.7%)30 (90.9%)118 (89.4%)
Charlson comorbidity index
  Score, median (min. - max.)1.0 (0.0 - 11.0)1.0 (0.0 - 6.0)2.0 (0.0 - 11.0)MW: 0.006
Gijon’s social-familial scale
  Score, median (min. - max.)7.5 (3.0 - 15.0)7. (3.0 - 15.0)8.0 (3.0 - 15.0)MW: 0.653
  Category, n (%)CS: 0.560
    High social risk30 (21.7%)4 (14.3%)26 (23.6%)
    Intermediate social risk71 (51.4%)16 (57.1%)55 (50.0%)
    Low social risk37 (26.8%)8 (28.6%)29 (26.4%)
Katz index
  Category, n (%)CSeT: 0.006
    A: Independent for all activities35 (21.2%)15 (45.5%)20 (15.2%)
    B: Independent for all activities except for one19 (11.5%)3 (9.1%)16 (12.1%)
    C: Independent for all activities except for bathing and an additional one28 (17.0%)8 (24.2%)20 (15.2%)
    D: Independent for all activities except for bathing, dressing and an additional one17 (10.3%)1 (3.0%)16 (12.1%)
    E: Independent for all activities except for bathing, dressing, going to bathroom and an additional one26 (15.8%)4 (12.1%)22 (16.7%)
    F: Independent for all activities except for bathing, dressing, going to the bathroom, transfer and an additional one31 (18.8%)2 (6.1%)29 (22.0%)
    G: Dependent for all activities5 (3.0%)0 (0.0%)5 (3.8%)
    H: Dependent for at least two functions, but not classified as C, D, E, and F4 (2.4%)0 (0.0%)4 (3.0%)
Lawton index
  Score, median (min. - max.)9.0 (0.0 - 16.0)12.0 (6.0 - 16.0)8.0 (0.0 - 16.0)MW < 0.001
  Category, n (%)CS < 0.001
    Severe or total dependency45 (28.3%)0 (0.0%)45 (35.4%)
    Moderate dependency74 (46.5%)15 (46.9%)59 (46.5%)
    Mild dependency or independency40 (25.2%)17 (53.1%)23 (18.1%)
Barthel index
  Score, median (min. - max.)65.0 (0.0 - 100.0)85.0 (35.0 - 100.0)61.5 (0.0 - 100.0)MW < 0.001
  Category, n (%)CS < 0.001
    Total dependency7 (4.3%)0 (0.0%)7 (5.4%)
    Severe dependency24 (14.7%)1 (3.0%)23 (17.7%)
    Moderate dependency42 (25.8%)7 (21.2%)35 (26.9%)
    Mild dependency90 (55.2%)25 (75.8%)65 (50.0%)
MMSE
  Score, median (min. - max.)26.0 (11.0 - 30.0)26.0 (12.0 - 30.0)25.0 (11.0 - 30.0)MW: 0.464
  Category, n (%)CS: 0.434
    With cognitive deficit75 (45.5%)13 (39.4%)62 (47.0%)
    Without cognitive deficit90 (54.5%)20 (60.6%)70 (53.0%)
HADS
  Score (depression), median (min. - max.)8.5 (0.0 - 20.0)4.0 (1.0 - 13.0)9.0 (0.0 - 20.0)MW < 0.001
  Category (depression), n (%)CS < 0.001
    With depression80 (50.0%)3 (9.1%)77 (60.6%)
    Without depression80 (50.0%)30 (90.9%)50 (39.4%)
  Score (anxiety), median (min. - max.)6.0 (0.0 - 17.0)4.0 (0.0 - 10.0)6.0 (0.0 - 17.0)MW < 0.001
  Category (anxiety), n (%)CS: 0.002
    With anxiety45 (28.1%)2 (6.1%)43 (33.9%)
    Without anxiety115 (71.9%)31 (93.9%)84 (66.1%)

 

Table 5. Assessment of Frailty With TFI for the Overall Sample
 
Total (n = 165)Non-frail (n = 33)Frail (n = 132)
Score B1 (physical domain), median (min. - max.)5.0 (0.0 - 8.0)2.0 (0.0 - 5.0)5.0 (1.0 - 8.0)
Score B2 (psychological domain), median (min. - max.)2.0 (0.0 - 4.0)1.0 (0.0 - 2.0)2.0 (0.0 - 4.0)
Score B3 (social domain), median (min. - max.)1.0 (0.0 - 3.0)1.0 (0.0 - 3.0)2.0 (0.0 - 3.0)
Final score, median (min. - max.)8.0 (0.0 - 15.0)4.0 (0.0 - 5.0)9.0 (6.0 - 15.0)
TFI: Tilburg frailty indicator; CI: confidence interval; min.: minimum; max.: maximum.
Frailtyn (%)95% CI
Non-frail (< 6)33 (20.0%)13.90-26.1%
Frail (≥ 6)132 (80.0%)73.9-86.1%

 

Table 6. Multivariate Logistic Regressions
 
aOR95% CI for aORP-value
aOR: adjusted odds ratio; 95% CI for aOR: 95% confidence interval for adjusted odds ratio; HADS: hospital anxiety and depression scale.
Age0.990.92 - 1.060.719
Sex (female)4.451.40 - 14.140.011
Vascular disease4.401.07 - 18.140.040
Vision problems10.853.04 - 38.70< 0.001
Lawton Index0.740.62 - 0.890.002
Depressive symptoms (HADS)1.371.37 - 1.640.001