Journal of Clinical Medicine Research, ISSN 1918-3003 print, 1918-3011 online, Open Access
Article copyright, the authors; Journal compilation copyright, J Clin Med Res and Elmer Press Inc
Journal website http://www.jocmr.org

Review

Volume 9, Number 9, September 2017, pages 733-744


Meniere’s Disease and Vestibular Migraine: Updates and Review of the Literature

Figure

Figure 1.
Figure 1. Study methodology - flow chart.

Tables

Table 1. Diagnostic Criteria for Vestibular Migraine Proposed by Neuhauser, 2001
 
Vestibular migraine, defined
  1) Vestibular symptoms at least of moderate intensity
  2) Current or past history of migraine, according to International Headache Society criteria
  3) One of the following migraine symptoms during at least two attacks of vertigo: migraine, photophobia, phonophobia, visual or other auras
  4) Other causes ruled out by an appropriate research
Probable vestibular migraine
  1) Vestibular symptoms of at least moderate intensity
  2) One of the following:
    a) Current or past history of migraine according to 2004 criteria
    b) Migraine symptoms during vestibular symptoms
    c) Migraine precipitants of vertigo in more than 50% of attacks: food triggers, sleep problems, hormonal changes
    d) Response to anti-migraine drugs in more than 50% of attacks
  3) Other causes ruled out by appropriate research

 

Table 2. Diagnostic Criteria for Vestibular Migraine Proposed by Barany Society and the Third International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD-3), 2012
 
aUsually interfere with daily activities. bUsually prohibit daily activities.
Vestibular migraine
  1) At least five episodes with vestibular symptoms of moderatea or severeb intensity, lasting 5 min to 72 h
  2) Current or previous history of migraine with or without aura according to the International Classification of Headache Disorders (ICHD)
  3) One or more migraine features with at least 50% of the vestibular episodes: a) headache with at least two of the following characteristics: one sided location, pulsating quality, moderatea or severeb pain intensity, aggravation of routine physical activity; b) photophobia and phonophobia; c) visual aura
  4) Not better accounted for by another vestibular or ICHD diagnosis
Probable vestibular migraine
  1) At least five episodes with vestibular symptoms of moderate or severe intensity, lasting 5 min to 72 h
  2) Only one of the criteria B and C for vestibular migraine is fulfilled (migraine history or migraine features during the episode)
  3) Not better accounted for by another vestibular or ICHD diagnosis

 

Table 3. The 1995 American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Diagnostic Criteria for Meniere’s Disease
 
Certain Meniere’s diseaseDefinite Meniere’s disease plus histopathologic confirmation
Definite Meniere’s diseaseTwo or more definitive spontaneous episodes of vertigo 20 minutes or longer
Audiometrically documented hearing loss on at least one occasion
Tinnitus or aural fullness in the treated ear
Other causes excluded
Probable Meniere’s diseaseOne definitive episode of vertigo
Audiometrically documented hearing loss on at least one occasion
Tinnitus or aural fullness in the treated ear
Other causes excluded
Possible Meniere’s diseaseEpisodic vertigo of the Meniere’s type without documented hearing loss or sensorineural hearing loss, fluctuating or fixed, with disequilibrium but without definitive episodes
Other causes excluded

 

Table 4. Comparisons in Historical Findings Between Meniere’s Disease (MD) and Vestibular Migraine (VM)
 
FindingsArticleCriteriaMDVMP-value
Nil: data not mentioned; ND: no difference noted but no P-value given; MSQ: motion sensitivity questionnaire; HL: hearing loss; HA: headache; Mod: moderate; Hx: history. Official: International Headache Society and Barany Society criteria (2012); Unofficial: Neuhauser criteria (2001).
Sex (female %)Neff et al [16]Unofficial3583< 0.0001
Martin-Sanz et al [20]OfficialNilNilND
Age (years)Hong et al [19]Unofficial4943ND
Martin-Sanz et al [20]Official4637ND
Age of onset (years)Neff et al [16]Unofficial51410.0007
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official48430.007
EvolutionMartin-Sanz et al [20]OfficialNilNilND
Vertigo Duration (hours)Neff et al [16]Unofficial4719< 0.0001
Illness duration (months)126< 0.0001
Non-vertiginous dizziness (%)5078< 0.0001
Fluctuating HL (%)7814< 0.0001
Progressive HL (%)9322< 0.0001
HL related to vertigo (%)43440.91
Tinnitus (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial9655< 0.0001
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official8346< 0.001
Tinnitus related to vertigo (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial59500.47
Aural Fullness (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial78510.0026
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official8034< 0.001
Aural Fullness related to vertigo (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial65700.71
Otalgia (%)17270.09
Palpitations (%)Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official34500.008
Anxiety (%)78910.024
Headache (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial81990.0026
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official4195< 0.001
Frequent headache (daily or weekly)Neff et al [16]Unofficial1967< 0.0001
Headache duration (> day)8430.0012
Headache severity (mod/severe) (%)2696< 0.0001
HA age of onset (years)23280.44
Migraine-type headache (%)Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official869< 0.001
Phonophobia (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial63820.1
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official6280< 0.001
Photophobia (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial4086< 0.0001
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official4180< 0.001
Nausea or vomiting with HA (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial2072< 0.0001
Vomiting (%)Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official84690.002
Headache triggers (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial1169< 0.0001
Balance symptoms with HA31810.07
Frequency of balance symptoms with HA2980< 0.0001
Aura (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial2262< 0.0001
Lopez-Escamez et al [18]Official1132< 0.001
Family Hx of vertigo or dizziness (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial17300.16
Family Hx of HL (%)33250.74
Family Hx of Migraine (%)26610.0017
History of motion sickness (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial20510.0023
MSQ score to riding in a carSharon et al [17]Unofficial0.51.070.048

 

Table 5. Comparisons in Physical Exam Findings, Auditory Tests Results and Endolymphatic Hydrops Between MD and VM
 
Findings (unit)ArticleCriteriaMDVMP-value
MD: Meniere’s disease; VM: vestibular Migraine; dMD: definite Meniere’s disease; dVM: definite vestibular migraine; pMD: probable Meniere’s disease; pVM: probable vestibular migraine; PTA: pure tone average; ELH: endolymphatic hydrops; ECOG: electrocochleography; dB: decibels; Nil: data not mentioned; D: difference noted but no P-value given; official: International Headache Society and Barany Society criteria (2012); unofficial: Neuhauser criteria (2001). Hearing class according to AAO-HNS hearing preservation reporting guidelines (view Table 7). SP: summating potential; AP: action potential.
Abnormal head-shaking nystagmus (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial6215< 0.0001
Shin et al [21]7150< 0.05
Abnormal head-thrust (%)Neff et al [16]373< 0.0001
Abnormal vibration induced nystagmus (%)Neff et al [16]6012< 0.0001
Shin et al [21]4232< 0.05
Abnormal smooth pursuit (%)Neff et al [16]580.09
Abnormal saccades (%)500.46
Initial PTA ≥ 25 dB (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial8370.0011
Worst PTA ≥ 25 dB (%)1009< 0.0001
Initial discrimination ≥ 25 dB (%)682< 0.0001
Change in discrimination (%/month)862< 0.0001
Initial hearing class B-D (%)715< 0.0001
Worst hearing class B-D (%)956< 0.0001
Low tone hearing loss pattern (%)400< 0.0001
PTA for dMD vs. dVM (dB)Martin-Sanz et al [20]OfficialNilNil> 0.05
PTA for pMD vs. pVM (dB)3516D
Significant vestibular ELH (%)Nakada et al [22]Official7914< 0.01
Significant Cochlear ELH (%)300< 0.05
ELH on ECOG (%) (SP/AP amplitude ratio)Martin-Sanz et al [20]8224< 0.05

 

Table 6. Comparisons in Vestibular Tests Results Between MD and VM
 
FindingsArticleCriteriaMDVMP-value
Hz: Hertz; TB: tone burst; vHIT: video head impulse test; hVOR: horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex; CAQEM: covert anti-compensatory quick eye movements; nil: data not mentioned; official: International Headache Society and Barany Society criteria (2012); unofficial: Neuhauser criteria (2001). oVEMP: ocular vestibular evoked myogenic potential; cVEMP: cervical vestibular evoked myogenic potential; µV: microvolt; ms: millisecond; mV: millivolt; ND: no difference noted but no P-value given.
Mean caloric asymmetry (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial3313< 0.0001
Blodow et al [23]Official38160.005
Sharon et al [17]Unofficial40240.0007
Abnormal caloric asymmetry (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial6317< 0.0001
Blodow et al [23]Official67220.002
Hong et al [19]Unofficial4823< 0.05
Shin et al [21]Unofficial4725< 0.05
Taylor et al [24]UnofficialOR = 26.36 for MD vs. VM< 0.001
Sensitivity = 74.5%
Martin-Sanz et al [20]OfficialNilNil> 0.05
Mean directional preponderance (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial19130.09
Abnormal directional preponderance (%)29150.15
Abnormal rotary chair phase (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial6818< 0.0001
Rotary chair gain towards affected ear (Hz)Neff et al [16]Unofficial2536< 0.0001
Taylor et al [24]Unofficial16250.014
Rotary chair gain towards unaffected ear (Hz)Taylor et al [24]Unofficial18230.165
Abnormal rotary chair TC towards affected ear (Hz)16250.009
Abnormal rotary chair TC towards un affected ear (Hz)17240.033
Abnormal rotary chair symmetry (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial35290.02
Abnormal vHIT hVOR gain (%)Blodow et al [23]Official3790.025
Presence of vHIT CAQEM (%)Heuberger et al [28]OfficialNilNil0.01
Abnormal VEMP (%)Neff et al [16]Unofficial45160.0068
cVEMP 250 Hz TB amplitude asymmetry ratios (%)Taylor et al [24]Unofficial405< 0.001 - 0.024
cVEMP 500 Hz TB amplitude asymmetry ratios (%)6010< 0.001 - 0.024
cVEMP 1 kHz TB amplitude asymmetry ratios (%)4015< 0.001 - 0.024
cVEMP 2 kHz TB amplitude asymmetry ratios (%)3015< 0.001 - 0.024
cVEMP 500 Hz/1kHz TB amplitude ratio0.891.110.007
cVEMP 500 Hz TB detection rate (%)Murofushi et al [25]Unofficial631000.0003
cVEMP mean corrected amplitudes0.591.490.001
cVEMP click amplitudes (µV)Zuniga et al [26]UnofficialNilNilND
cVEMP click peak-to-peak amplitudes (µV)29380.625
cVEMP click latencies (ms)NilNilND
cVEMP click amplitudes for right sideBaier et al [27]UnofficialNilNil0.22
cVEMP click amplitudes for left side (ms)NilNil0.744
cVEMP click latencies p13 right side (ms)1616> 0.01
cVEMP click latencies p13 left side (ms)1616> 0.01
cVEMP click latencies n23 right side (ms)2525> 0.01
cVEMP click latencies n23 left side (ms)2625> 0.01
oVEMP click reflex latencies (ms)Zuniga et al [26]Unofficial11.19.80.028
oVEMP 500 Hz TB reflex latencies (ms)11.110.40.041
oVEMP 500 Hz TB reflex amplitudes0.983.40.007
oVEMP reflex hammer midline tap amplitudes (mV)4.65.450.21
oVEMP mini-shaker tap amplitudes (mV)3.950.217
oVEMP reflex hammer midline tap latencies (ms)87.50.879
oVEMP reflex mini-shaker tap latencies (ms)9.89.80.597

 

Table 7. 1995 American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery Hearing Preservation Reporting Guidelines
 
ClassPure-tone thresholdsSpeech discrimination (%)
A≤ 30 dB≥ 70
B> 30 dB, ≤ 50 dB≥ 50
C> 50 dB≥ 50
DAny level< 50

 

Table 8. Amended 2015 Criteria for Diagnosis of MD by the European Academy of Otology and Neurotology
 
DefiniteTwo or more spontaneous episodes of vertigo, each lasting 20 min to 12h
Audiometrically documented low to midfrequency sensorineural hearing loss in one ear, defining the ear on one occasion before, during or after one episode of vertigo
Fluctuating aural symptoms (hearing, tinnitus, or fullness) in the affected ear
Not better accounted for by another vestibular diagnosis
ProbableTwo or more episodes of vertigo or dizziness, each lasting 20 min to 24 h
Fluctuating aural symptoms (hearing, tinnitus, or fullness) in the affected ear
Not better accounted for by another vestibular diagnosis